Which creative won
The outcome image won on delivery cost.
A's link CTR was close to C's (2.91% vs. 2.76%), but it drew more than twice the total engagement, ran at less than half the CPM, and cost $2.48 per landing page view against C's $12.39. Meta gave it 61% of the budget.
| Creative | Spend (AUD) | Impressions | CPM | Link CTR | All-clicks CTR | CPC | Link clicks | Page views | Cost / page view |
| A. Outcome: Team Harmony | $497.80 (61%) | 32,275 | $15.42 | 2.91% | 6.38% | $0.53 | 938 | 201 | $2.48 |
| C. Product mockup | $284.87 (35%) | 8,289 | $34.37 | 2.76% | 3.63% | $1.24 | 229 | 23 | $12.39 |
| B. Identity: Lead, Don't Manage | $34.31 (4%) | 1,066 | $32.19 | 1.50% | 3.00% | $2.14 | 16 | 1 | $34.31 |
| Total | $821.59 | 41,901 | $19.61 | 2.82% | 5.75% | $0.69 | 1,183 | 225 | $3.65 |
Meta Ads Manager export, Aug 23 to Nov 29, 2025. Reach 18,851 people, 2.22 average frequency.
Why the outcome image won
It met managers where they already were. They think the problem is their team, the image promised to help with the team, and the copy then turned it around to "look in the mirror". The D-I-S-C circles named a specific tool, so the offer looked concrete.
Meta's auction rewards engagement with cheaper reach, which is why A's CPM was less than half the others.
How I read the other two
C was clicked almost as often as A, but only 10% of its clicks reached a loaded page, against 21% for A, and it cost more than twice as much to show. The product shot answers "what do I get?" before a cold viewer cares, so it fits retargeting better.
B was barely tested: about $34 isn't enough to call it a loser. On a cold scroll, a lone leader with an unnamed quote card looks like every other coaching ad and carries no proof.
How to read this: all three images ran inside one ad and Meta decided how to split the budget, so it wasn't an even-split A/B test. I also don't rank the images by Meta's "leads": they matched landing page views almost exactly for every image (199 vs. 201, 26 vs. 23, 1 vs. 1), which means the pixel fired on page load. Clicks, delivery cost and cost per page view are the honest comparison.